Trust
Judging & Trust
Last updated: 12 November 2026
A photography award is only worth what people trust it to be. This page explains, in plain words, how we judge, what we allow, what we check, and what happens if something goes wrong. It supplements the Official Rules; if the two ever differ, the Official Rules apply.
01Our promise
- Anonymous. Jurors judge the image and its title, never your name or country.
- Merit only. Fees, packages, Studio services and free entries have no influence on the result.
- Independent. Nobody judges a photograph by a relative, student or close associate, and nobody scores their own work.
- Verified. Before results are published we may check the original files of Finalists, Honorable Mentions and winners.
- Honest about AI. Generative AI has its own category, and we say clearly where it is and is not allowed.
- Fair if something goes wrong. You are told the reason, you can reply, and the refund rules are written down.
02How judging works
- Screening. The Founder and Artistic Curator checks every entry against the rules, the category and the file requirements, and removes entries that do not comply. Where there is still time before the deadline, we tell you what is wrong so you can replace the image.
- Scoring. Scoring opens only after the submission deadline. Each juror scores every photograph from 1 to 10. The order of photographs is different for every juror, so no image is always seen first or last. A juror never sees their own images and can abstain on any photograph they recognise.
- Final selection. Photographs are ranked by their average score. The jury then selects the Finalists and Honorable Mentions and the overall Gold, Silver and Bronze. When scores are tied, the jury discusses the photographs and votes again. Results are published only after the verification below.
Individual scores are never published. Only awarded works are announced; entries that are not selected are not listed. The AI-Generated Images category is judged on its own and is not eligible for the overall awards.
03Judging criteria
Each photograph receives one score that reflects four criteria, considered together:
| Criterion | What jurors look for |
|---|---|
| Creativity | A fresh idea, a personal point of view, a picture that does not look like many others. |
| Technical quality | Light, focus, composition, colour and tone, and a finish that serves the idea. Technical skill matters, but a technically perfect picture without an idea does not win. |
| Emotional impact | The power to make a viewer stop, feel or think. |
| Interpretation | How well the photograph answers the category or, in a Monthly Competition, the theme. |
We do not judge the camera, the country, the entrant’s reputation or the number of photographs entered.
04AI and editing policy
The test is simple: a photograph must record something that was in front of your camera. Editing may refine it; it may not invent it.
| Allowed in every category | Not allowed (except AI-Generated Images) |
|---|---|
| Exposure, contrast, colour, white balance, cropping, straightening, dodging and burning, black-and-white conversion. | Generative fill, expand or replace, or any AI that creates pixels that were not captured. |
| Noise reduction, sharpening, lens correction and AI-assisted masks or selections. | Adding or removing people, animals or objects, other than dust and sensor spots. |
| Removing dust and sensor spots. | Replacing a sky or background; composites made with images that are not your own. |
| Focus stacking, HDR merging and panoramas made from your own frames of the same scene. | Images created wholly or mainly by a generative AI model from a text or image prompt. |
Stricter categories. In Photojournalism & Documentary and Wildlife & Nature nothing may be added, removed or moved, and only global adjustments and minor dodging and burning are allowed. Staged scenes must be declared in Photojournalism & Documentary and are not accepted in Wildlife & Nature. Fine Art allows composites and creative manipulation, provided every photographic element is your own work. Monthly Competitions may set their own limits in the call for entries.
AI-Generated Images. This category in the Annual Awards is open to images made wholly or mainly with generative AI. You must declare it, and we may ask you for the prompt or the workflow. These images are judged only against each other.
No automatic AI-detector decides a case by itself. Concerns are checked through the original files, the metadata, the visual evidence and, if needed, expert opinion, and the entrant can always reply first.
05Verification of original files
Before results are published, we may ask any Finalist, Honorable Mention or Gold, Silver or Bronze winner for the original file of the winning photograph.
- What to send. The RAW file from your camera or phone (for example DNG, CR3, NEF, ARW), or the unedited JPEG or HEIC if you do not shoot RAW. For film, the scan of the negative or slide, or a photograph of it. For merged or stacked images, the source frames.
- How. Reply to the email we send you with a download link (WeTransfer, Google Drive, Dropbox or similar). No account on our side is needed.
- Deadline. 7 days from our email. If you need more time, ask before it ends and we will agree a new date.
- What we check. That the original is the same scene and frame as the entry and that the editing stays inside the rules of the category. Missing metadata is not a reason to disqualify, because many apps strip it.
- If you cannot provide it. Tell us within the 7 days. We can accept other proof, such as neighbouring frames or a short making-of. If no satisfactory proof is given, the entry may be disqualified.
- Your file stays private. It is used only for this check, never published or shared, and is deleted within 90 days after the results are published.
06Conflicts of interest
- Who cannot enter. Members of the jury of a competition, employees of the Organizer and their immediate family and household members may not enter that competition.
- Declaration. Before judging begins every juror declares any relationship with an entrant that could affect their judgement: family, partner, business partner, employer, client, student or teacher, or close friend.
- Abstaining. A juror does not score a photograph by anyone they have such a relationship with, or that they recognise. The system also never shows jurors their own images.
- No influence. Entry fees, Studio services, magazine publication and sponsorship have no influence on scores. Jurors do not see how an entry was paid for.
- Contacting jurors. Entrants must not contact jurors about their entries while a competition is open or being judged.
- If a conflict is found later. The juror’s scores for that entrant’s photographs are removed and the ranking is recalculated before results are published. If the results are already published and the outcome changes, we correct them and tell those affected.
07Disqualification
We may disqualify an entry, before or after the results, if:
- the entrant is not eligible, or gave false information or a false identity;
- the photograph is not the entrant’s own work, or copies someone else’s;
- the photograph breaks the AI and editing policy or the rules of its category;
- a requested original file or proof is not provided within the time allowed;
- the entrant contacted a juror to influence the result, or created several accounts to get more free images;
- the payment was fraudulent or was reversed without a valid reason.
Process.
- We write to you with the reason and the evidence we have.
- You have 7 days to reply and send your own evidence.
- The Founder and two jurors who are not involved in the case decide, and you receive the decision in writing with its reason.
Consequences. The entry is removed. If a title was already awarded, the title, certificate and badge are withdrawn and the winner is removed from the website and future material. Printed issues of the magazine cannot be recalled. A cash prize already paid must be returned within 30 days. The next eligible entry may be promoted and notified.
08Refunds
| Situation | Refund |
|---|---|
| You ask within 14 days of payment, before the deadline and before judging starts | Full refund |
| After the deadline or once judging has started | No refund, unless the law of your country requires it |
| We cancel or suspend a competition | Full refund to every entrant |
| The rules change in a way that disadvantages you after you paid | Full refund on request |
| A fault on our side: double charge, entry not recorded, file lost or damaged | Full refund, or free re-entry if you prefer |
| We cannot accept your entry or payment because of sanctions or other legal limits | Anything you paid is returned |
| You are disqualified for breaking the rules | No refund |
To ask for a refund, use the contact form and give the email you ordered with. Approved refunds go back to the original payment method through Stripe, normally within 10 business days, depending on your bank. Image credits cannot be exchanged for cash outside these cases.
09Frequently asked questions
Who judges my photographs?
An international jury of photographers, editors and curators, listed on our website. The Founder and Artistic Curator, the Editor-in-Chief and the Art Director sit on the jury of every competition; other jurors join per competition and are added to the website when they join.
Do the jurors know who I am?
No. Jurors see only the image and its title. They never see your name, country, age or account. Please do not put your name, a watermark or a signature on the image.
Will I get feedback on my photographs?
We do not give individual scores or written feedback. Scores are confidential so that jurors can judge freely. Only awarded works are announced.
Does paying for more images improve my chances?
No. Every image is judged on its own merit. A free image, a Starter, Artist or Master package and Studio services all have exactly the same chance, and the jury cannot see how an image was paid for.
Can I use Lightroom, Photoshop or other AI tools?
Yes, for normal photographic editing: exposure, colour, contrast, cropping, dodging and burning, black-and-white conversion, noise reduction, sharpening, lens correction, AI masks and removing sensor dust. Generative AI that adds, replaces or removes content is not allowed, except in the AI-Generated Images category. See the AI and editing policy above for the full list.
Can I enter a photograph made with AI?
Only in the AI-Generated Images category of the Annual Awards, and you must declare it. AI-generated images are not eligible in any other category and not for the overall Gold, Silver and Bronze.
Why might I be asked for my RAW file?
Finalists, Honorable Mentions and overall winners may be asked to send the original file so we can confirm authorship and that the rules were followed. You will have 7 days. The file is used only for this check.
I shoot JPEG, film or with a phone. Can I still win?
Yes. Send the original JPEG, HEIC or DNG from your device, or for film the scan of the negative or slide (or a photograph of it). Missing metadata alone is never a reason to disqualify you.
What if I lost my RAW file?
Tell us before the 7 days end. We can accept other proof, such as the neighbouring frames of the same shoot or a short making-of. Each case is decided fairly by the review panel.
A juror is a friend or a student of mine. Is that a problem?
Jurors declare such relationships before judging begins and do not score your image. Entrants who are jurors, staff or their family cannot enter that competition at all.
Can I contact a juror about my entry?
Please do not contact jurors about your entry while a competition is open or being judged. Doing so can lead to disqualification. Write to us through the contact form instead.
Can I be disqualified after winning?
Yes, if it is found that a rule was broken, for example the image is not yours or breaks the AI policy. You will always be told the reason and can reply first. A prize already paid must be returned.
Can I get a refund?
Yes. You can have a full refund within 14 days of payment, as long as the entry deadline has not passed and judging has not started. If we cancel a competition, or the fault is ours, you are refunded in full. See the refunds section for every case.
I disagree with a decision. What can I do?
The jury’s decisions on scores and rankings are final. If you think a factual mistake was made, for example the wrong image was judged or a file was damaged, write to us within 14 days of the result and the review panel will look at it.
Are my photographs ever sold or given to others?
Never. You keep the copyright. We do not sell your images or prints of them and do not license them to third parties. Details are in the Official Rules.
Questions about judging? Use the contact form. This English version is the binding version. Translations, where offered, are for convenience only.
